Here’s a test regarding the effectiveness of your advertising: WSAC?
What’s a WSAC, you ask? It stands for Why Should Anyone Care?
WSAC is a stronger, more cynical way of asking WIIFM (What’s In It For Me?), the unspoken question we all subconsciously inquire when looking at commercial messages. You have to be cynical because, sure as shooting, your audience is.
So much advertising fails in one of two ways. Either it’s all about the product (or service) and not the buyer, or it’s way too clever for its own good. In either case, the question left at the end of the commercial or as the eyes are turning away is WSAC.
How many times have you seen a funeral home ad in which the headline is nothing more than the name of the funeral home. WSAC?
Or “Serving Families For Generations.” WSAC?
Or “The Caring People to Turn To.” WSAC?
Or even the vaunted “Celebrate A Life.” So what? What’s in it for me? Who gives a $%#@? Why should anyone care?
An audience overwhelmed by thousands of commercial messages every day isn’t going to take the time to contemplate an ad that doesn’t speak to their own needs quickly, honestly, clearly and compellingly.
So the first step in building your marketing is to give serious thought about what kind of message would a disinterested audience CARE about, that affects them personally and expresses how their lives are made better by reading further…particularly when it comes to marketing funeral services that by nature no one really wants even if it’s something everybody needs. And then, once you’ve crafted that message, the next step is to come up with a compelling, eye-stopping – I might even say disruptive – way of communicating that message within the headline and art.
You can say it funny. You can say it emotionally. You can even say it simply. But the result has to be that the audience has a near-instant reason to care, or you’ve just flushed more of your precious marketing dollars down the proverbial toilet.
It pays to be cynical in analyzing your own advertising. Or at least, put yourself in the mindset of a disinterested reader and don’t assume that just because you advertise they will come. You must understand WHY they should care if they’ve never heard of you before and they have so many other choices, including not to act at all. This is what should drive your advertising message, whether it’s in a magazine, on the web or on a bus bench.
And to better hone your skills at this, look at ads from other advertisers and see if they tell the story compellingly, or do they prompt you to ask WSAC. If you have to ask, they’ve missed the mark.
Just be sure others don’t ask that when looking at your ads.
Advertising creative director Dan Katz started his first ad agency, LA ads, during the recession of the early 90’s and built it into one of the top independents in Los Angeles. Now Katz has announced that he is re-launching LA ads, again during a recession, and he’s confident that he’ll find similar success. This time, the agency is called LA ads – A Marketing Agency.
For Katz, a dramatic change in the economy represents a great opportunity to reach clients who are ready to embrace change in their marketing programs. That is why he has boldly labeled his new agency an “Agent of Change.”
“Being an Agent of Change is more than a cool slogan,” says Katz. “It defines our agency’s mission, which is to disrupt marketing patterns that no longer work for our clients and help them actively set a new direction for success. We take it very seriously. In fact, on every staff member’s business card, ‘Agent of Change’ is their official title regardless of their job.”
Between the first and second iterations of LA ads, the marketing world has vastly changed, said Katz. He points out that it’s more than just how the Internet has affected communications, it’s about how much more empowered the consumer is to control what he listens to, when and where.
At the same time, Katz says, advertisers have changed, in part because of the economy and in part because their audiences are more elusive than ever.
“Marketers are understandably frustrated,” added Katz. “They don’t know whether to run commercials, send out Tweets, put up a Facebook page, or all or none of them. The rules are being re-written every day. But the fundamentals of marketing really haven’t changed. Customers still need a meaningful reason to buy that improves the quality of their life in some way. And that’s where we can bring some sanity to the conversation.”
Among the services LA ads offers its clients are Strategic Marketing Counsel, Advertising Creative & Production, Media Planning & Purchasing, New Media/Internet Marketing, Market Research, Direct Response Marketing, Promotions & Merchandising, Branding & Corporate Identity and Public Relations.
The agency’s clients currently include Arbor Memorial Services, Z Mei Skin Care Products, Qmulo Tech, Hollywood Aviators and Regal Aircraft, along with several other clients in the consumer electronics, healthcare and financial services industries.
Katz said he was deliberate in having a diverse and eclectic range of clients. “We believe that good ideas cross-pollinate. Because we’re working across a wide range of industries, we are continually learning and applying new and more powerful tools to help affect change for our clients. And frankly, it’s a lot more fun jumping from cool gadgets to funeral homes and then back to mortgage lending. It’s never boring.”
The Website for LA ads is: http://www.LAadsMarketing.com.
The company phone number is (800) 991-0625
About Dan Katz
With more than 30 years as producer, copywriter, creative director, and founder of one of LA’s top independent agencies, Dan puts his distinctive stamp on all aspects of his clients’ marketing programs. Over the course of his career, Dan has produced successful, award-winning advertising for such diverse clients as Alpine Electronics, Infinity, Kaufman & Broad, Mount Sinai Memorial Parks, Sears, Salvation Army, Vivitar and 20th Century Fox. Outside the agency, Dan frequently guest-lecturers at the university graduate level on advertising and creativity. He is listed in the Who’s Who in American Advertising. Dan is an avid private pilot and has some of his best ideas while flying his classic 1957 Beech Bonanza.
Today I attended a meeting of angels. No, not the kind with wings but the more earthly ones with money to invest. Presenting to them were a bevy of start-up companies looking to become the next big thing. As each presented his (I’m not sexist; they were all guys) story, I was surprised at how uniformly they said they intended to market using social media alone. OK, they were trying to prove to possible investors that they would be frugal with the marketing dollars – and sure, Twitter and Facebook are free, at least on the surface. They figured that it would require only minimal spend to influence their customers to Tweet or post their enthusiastic endorsements to their BFF’s on Facebook, and then the rest would fall into place.
First, I have to admit, these guys were mostly in their 30’s (and I’m just “slightly” older) so they are more comfortable adapting to every new gadget and app. But they are also focusing on the wrong thing. It’s not the medium du jour that’s important here. It’s the message. The horse always has to go ahead of the cart and not the other way around. It’s a mistake to be thinking about where to tell the message without having decided on exactly what the right message is, given the product and the buyer. Maybe social media is the right medium, maybe it’s not – but it should always be the message that drives where and how the story is to be told. And these guys have already settled on Twitter!
Frankly, I don’t believe the Internet pundits have it right when they tout Social Media as the new and only way to go and claim that “push” advertising (they call it Marketing 1.0) is dead. Sound marketing strategy requires a combination of both push and pull. Tell the consumer about the product and then help them tell each other.
My point is, don’t get so enamored of some “hot” new marketing technique as to forget the basics. The right message, strategically developed, skillfully crafted and inventively told will win out in any medium. It’s about message first and foremost. That’s when the angels sing.
Seeking good ideas from within your own industry is just a step away from examining your own navel. It’s incestuous thinking. What you need in order to grow is to branch out. And how you do that is by looking at industries and businesses outside your own.